Back to Directory
Matthews & Nulty, Inc.

Matthews & Nulty, Inc.

Reviews Summary

The consensus is overwhelmingly positive, with all reviewers giving 5-star ratings. Customers consistently praise the professionalism, expertise, and responsiveness of the accounting team, particularly in tax and financial matters. Many highlight the personalized attention, quick responses to queries, and significant tax savings. The firm is commended for its reliability, clear communication, and ability to handle both personal and business needs seamlessly. Long-term clients express strong loyalty, emphasizing trust and satisfaction with the services. The team is described as knowledgeable, patient, and highly recommended for all accounting needs.

About This Listing

Audit
Business Consulting
Financial Statements
Payroll
Tax Preparation
Budgeting
Virtual CFO
Small Businesses
Mid-size Businesses
Non-profits
Real Estate
Professional Services
QuickBooks

Who Can Work with a CPA?

Individuals seeking tax prep, retirement planning, or financial advice
Small business owners needing bookkeeping, payroll, or tax compliance
Freelancers and contractors with 1099 income or complex returns
Couples planning finances together or managing joint returns
Investors with capital gains or rental property income
Anyone looking for year-round financial guidance and peace of mind

*Note: CPAs may specialize in different areas. Be sure to check credentials and service offerings.*

First-Time Clients

If this is your first time working with a CPA, don’t worry — most professionals offer a free consultation and will walk you through what to expect. You may be asked to complete an intake form, share financial documents, or set clear goals for your session.

What to Know Upfront:

Documentation Bring your most recent tax returns, income details, and any financial concerns
Availability Appointments fill up quickly during tax season — book early if possible

*Note: Every CPA operates a bit differently. Don’t hesitate to ask questions before committing.*

What to Bring

Government-issued ID for verification
Tax documents (W-2s, 1099s, investment summaries, etc.)
Receipts or logs for deductible expenses, donations, or mileage

*Tip: Organize your documents in advance to save time and ensure accuracy.*

Preparing for Your Appointment

Write down any financial goals or questions in advance
Check if your CPA offers virtual sessions or document uploads
Bring a notebook or use a notes app for key takeaways
Know your deadlines for filing, payments, or compliance

*Note: Preparation helps you make the most of your CPA’s expertise.*

How to Get Started

Use our directory to find highly reviewed CPAs near you. Reach out directly to schedule your consultation.

Other Helpful Info

Many CPAs offer both in-person and remote consultations
Fees may be flat-rate, hourly, or based on service complexity
Some CPAs specialize in industries like healthcare, real estate, or tech
Check for client reviews and credentials (CPA license, EA, etc.)

*Note: Every CPA is different — take time to find one who fits your goals and style.*

Features

Audit
Business Consulting
Financial Statements
Payroll
Tax Preparation
Budgeting
Virtual CFO
Small Businesses
Mid-size Businesses
Non-profits
Real Estate
Professional Services
QuickBooks

Contact Information

Address

Turnpike Plaza, 197 NJ-18 Suite #202N

East Brunswick, New Jersey 08816

Visit Website Call Now Get Directions

Hours

Sunday Closed
Monday 9AM-5PM
Tuesday 9AM-5PM
Wednesday 9AM-5PM
Thursday 9AM-5PM
Friday 9AM-5PM
Saturday Closed

Customer Reviews

I found Mike through word of mouth. He is very professional, prompt with appointments and follows through with his work. Wish I could of found him sooner. I hope this 5 star review will give the prospective client a reason to stop searching and call you now.

I?ve had Mike do my taxes for several years. He?s Incredibly professional, super responsive and helpful. If you need an appointment he takes his time and is incredibly patient. I?ve always been thrilled when working with him! He adapts and helps me with things I should keep in mind, always reminding me of things I need to think about. He truly cares and is a consummate professional! Thanks so much for being so fantastic to work with Mike. Highly recommend! Thank you!

Mike was extremely helpful in assisting my father and I navigate our tax returns. Mike was highly informed on the tax code, earnest and a clear communicator. He answered all of our questions and gave us the answers we needed to make the best possible decision. I would highly recommend Mike and his team for all of your accounting needs.

Matthews & Nulty is the best experience I have had with any accountants to date. I was starting to get discourage with the industry until I found this amazing team! They are super professional, very responsive, have a fast turn around time & extremely wonderful attitudes. I cannot recommend them enough. Best accountant firm.

Michael Nulty has been my tax accountant for the past 7 years. He is a true professional and is he well versed in both NY and NJ state tax. He also advised me on estate matters. Michael is very attentive to his clients, whenever I need a quick answer to a tax question Mike is quick to respond.

It has been a pleasure working with Matthews and Nulty, Inc. for the past several years. My husband and I have been working with Michael Nulty, specifically, and it has been nothing but a smooth process. Michael has shown an abundance of knowledge on the laws and regulations on tax laws. He takes the time to work with you and explain any questions in great detail, ANYTIME of the day and year. Whenever we have a question he makes himself available and speaks with us in a timely manner. I have referred many

I highly recommend using Matthews and Nulty Inc. They have been my go to accountants for years since I began my professional career. Mike and his team have always provided the best in class financial services while giving me an incredible customer service experience. I have lost count of the times Mike or one of his partners went above and beyond to help me when I was building a business. They would always make time to provide solid professional advice and would go out of the way to help, anyway they co

Michael and the entire team at Matthew?s and Nulty have been such a pleasure to work with over the years as I grew my business. They are always quick to respond and help in any way possible. They make me feel comfortable and I trust them with all my finance needs!

Matthews & Nulty has been a GODSEND especially during this Pandemic. They were very instrumental in handling my PPP SBA Loan for my business otherwise I was going to be in trouble. Mike has always been available to me to talk & explain complicated tax matters. Deanna has been great as well! This is a TOP-NOTCH organization & I highly recommend them for ALL of your tax matters.

Most professional and helpful accounting firm I have ever worked with! Mike Nulty was able to get the most out of my tax return and was a pleasure to work with. I would highly recommend Matthews & Nulty to anyone looking for a reliable and reputable accountant.

Matthews & Nulty is an excellent accounting form and a great group of people. Whether a start-up or a long-standing institution, Matthews & Nulty offers a totally new perspective to the world of accounting. I know for certain as Matthews & Nulty has been with since the inception of my company. Give them a call you won?t be disappointed!

Couldn't recommend them more. Mike Nulty has been handling my personal and business taxes for years. He's knowledgeable and always there to answer any questions. The whole staff is excellent.

Absolutely love Mike and his team! Supreme knowledge of the tax code for both individuals and business. Their client portal is extremely useful.

Mr Nulty is a professional, reliable and smart CPA. His eye is on always saving money for his clients. He can be counted on and trusted.

Absolutely the best experience you can have getting your taxes done! I am so grateful I found them! I highly recommend Mike and the team for a seamless and professional experience.

My companies have been using Matthews & Nulty for 5 years. I know that when I have a question the team is there to answer it for me. I moved to Florida 3 years ago and still have the M&N Team by my side.

Customer for over 4 years. The owner, Mike, really cares about his clients, I have been highly satisfied with his services.

Fantastic CPA. Always available for professional tax advise even when I have random questions. Has saved me $1,000's in taxes over the years.

Great service great price. 10/10 would recommend

Great tax professional highly recommend!

Would not go to anyone else for my taxes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What qualifications should I look for in a CPA?

Look for a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) license, which ensures they’ve passed rigorous exams and meet state requirements. Check for relevant experience in your industry, additional certifications like CFA or CMA, and membership in professional organizations like the AICPA. Verify their credentials through state licensing boards.

How do I find a CPA in my area?

Use online directories like the AICPA, CPAverify, or state CPA societies. Search platforms like Yelp or Google for local CPAs with reviews. Ask for referrals from business associates, friends, or financial advisors. Local chambers of commerce can also provide recommendations.

What’s the difference between a CPA and an accountant?

A CPA is a licensed professional who has passed the CPA exam and met state requirements for education and experience. An accountant may lack this certification and could have varying levels of expertise. For complex tasks like tax audits or financial reporting, a CPA is typically more qualified.

How do I know if a CPA specializes in my needs?

Ask about their experience with your specific financial needs, such as tax preparation, small business accounting, or estate planning. Review their website or LinkedIn for case studies or client testimonials. Inquire about their client base to ensure they handle similar financial situations.

Should I check a CPA’s reviews before hiring?

Yes, reviews provide insight into a CPA’s reliability, communication, and performance. Check platforms like Google, Yelp, or the Better Business Bureau for client feedback. Look for patterns in reviews, but verify their authenticity, as some may be biased or outdated.

How can I verify a CPA’s license?

Visit your state’s Board of Accountancy website or use CPAverify.org to check a CPA’s license status. Confirm their license is active and check for any disciplinary actions or complaints. This ensures they’re in good standing and meet professional standards.

What questions should I ask during a CPA consultation?

Ask about their experience with your financial needs, fee structure, availability, and communication style. Inquire how they handle tax filings, audits, or financial planning. Ask for references or examples of similar work to assess their expertise and fit.

How much should I expect to pay for a CPA’s services?

Fees vary based on location, services, and complexity. Basic tax preparation may cost $150-$500, while business accounting or audits can range from $1,000 to $10,000+. Request a detailed fee structure upfront and compare quotes from multiple CPAs.

Can I work with a CPA remotely?

Yes, many CPAs offer remote services through secure online platforms for document sharing and virtual consultations. Ensure they use encrypted tools for data security. Remote CPAs can be effective if they understand your local tax laws or business regulations.

How do I assess a CPA’s communication skills?

During consultations, evaluate their ability to explain complex financial concepts clearly. Ask sample questions about taxes or financial strategies and note their responsiveness and clarity. Good communication ensures you understand their advice and fosters a productive relationship.

What red flags should I watch for when screening a CPA?

Beware of CPAs who guarantee specific tax refunds, lack a valid license, or have disciplinary actions on record. Avoid those with poor communication, vague fee structures, or negative reviews highlighting unethical behavior. Always verify their credentials independently.

Should I choose a CPA from a large firm or a solo practitioner?

Large firms offer more resources and specialized teams but may charge higher fees. Solo practitioners often provide personalized service and lower costs but may have limited availability. Choose based on your needs, budget, and preference for personalized attention.

How often should I meet with my CPA?

For individuals, annual meetings for tax preparation may suffice. Businesses may need quarterly or monthly check-ins for bookkeeping, tax planning, or financial reporting. Discuss your needs upfront to establish a meeting schedule that aligns with your financial goals.

Can a CPA help with both personal and business finances?

Yes, many CPAs handle both, but confirm their expertise in both areas. Ask about their experience managing personal taxes and business accounting simultaneously. Ensure they can balance both without compromising attention to your specific financial needs.

What should I do if I’m not satisfied with my CPA?

Discuss concerns directly with your CPA to resolve issues. If unresolved, check your contract for termination terms. Seek a new CPA by researching reviews, credentials, and referrals. Request your financial records to ensure a smooth transition to a new professional.

Skip to main Home Best CPA's Nearby Upgrade your plans English Avatar for Nico Bottema Welcome, Nico Bottema! Share Install the tag on your site to get access to all features, tools and the insights you need. It's fast and easy. Site ID: 6455700 Get started with the tag installation 1 Copy this code. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Copy code 2 Paste the code into the of every page where you want to track user behavior or collect feedback. 3 To make sure everything is ready, verify that your code was installed. Verify installation OTHER WAYS TO INSTALL Install with a team member’s help Install on a platform Install with a npm package Explore the demo Take a tour of the product with realistic data to explore. Explore demo site Common questions View all Course How do I install the tag? Collect session data for replays, heatmaps, and on-site surveys by installing a unique tag on your site. Ready to add it? Follow the instructions in this 15-minute course. Article How do I know if the tag is installed correctly? Article Will the tag slow down my site? Suggested for you Enable 2FA now Two-factor authentication (2FA) adds an additional layer of security to your account. Popular shortcuts title Feedback button Capture feedback in the wild by letting users share it at any point title Set up a Net Promoter Score® survey Measure long-term customer loyalty and happiness the tried-and-tested way. title Exit-intent survey Capture feedback before visitors leave and reduce your bounce rate Get started Interviews (new) Get real time feedback at critical times, thanks to easy, in-depth recruitment and analysis. Create project Finish your installation Surveys Feedback button Dashboard Invite team members Integrations